How to Choose a Dental Marketing Agency: 5 Questions to Ask Before You Sign
Choosing a dental marketing agency sounds simple enough. Find a few agencies, compare their services, look at their results, and pick the one that seems like the best fit.
But there’s a problem.
An agency can be great at marketing itself and still be completely wrong for your dental practice.
So, how do you separate a good dental marketing agency from one that’s simply good at selling?
I’m Art, founder of Growdent. We work with dental practices on their marketing, so I’ve seen how these relationships work from the agency side.
Here are five questions I’d recommend asking before hiring a dental marketing agency, along with examples of what good (and not-so-good) answers actually sound like.
Watch Art, Growdent’s CEO, explain the five questions he’d ask before hiring a dental marketing agency.
Table of Contents
1. Do they understand what your dental practice is trying to achieve?
Not every dental practice needs the same marketing strategy.
One practice might have a new associate with an almost empty schedule. Another might be fully booked for general dentistry but want to grow its implant or Invisalign treatments.
And then there’s the practice that’s already getting plenty of inquiries but struggling to turn them into appointments.
Would you recommend the same marketing strategy to all three?
Of course not.
Yet some agencies seem ready to recommend Google Ads, SEO, and social media marketing before they’ve even asked about your practice.
That’s a problem.
A good agency should spend time understanding your practice before telling you what services you need. During your first conversation, pay attention to the questions they ask. Are they interested in your goals, available appointment capacity, treatment mix, insurance mix, budget, and current marketing results?
Or are they spending most of the conversation explaining their services?
The questions an agency asks can tell you a lot about how it approaches marketing. But it’s also worth turning the conversation around and asking them to explain their thinking.
A good question to ask is: “What would you prioritize in our first 90 days, and why?”
What a weak answer sounds like
“We’ll run Google Ads and SEO to bring more patients to your practice.”
That’s not necessarily a bad recommendation. Google Ads and SEO can both be excellent channels for dental practices.
But it doesn’t explain why those services make sense for your situation.
What a better answer sounds like
“You’re looking to grow implant consultations, but your website currently sends everyone to a general services page. We’d start with a dedicated implant landing page, run a focused advertising campaign, and track which inquiries actually turn into consultations.”
See the difference?
The second answer identifies a specific problem, recommends a solution, and explains how you’ll measure the outcome.
You can also follow up with a few practical questions. What happens first? When will you review the results? What will the agency need from your team?
I’m not suggesting an agency should provide a complete marketing strategy for free before you’ve signed anything.
But they should be able to give you a short written plan explaining their priorities, assumptions, and approach.
Key takeaway: Look for an agency that recommends services based on your practice’s goals, not one that tries to sell you the same package it sells everyone else.
2. How will they measure whether your marketing is working?
Let’s say two dental marketing agencies are showing you their advertising results.
Both campaigns had a $5,000 budget. The first generated 60 leads and brought in 10 new patients. The second generated only 40 leads, but brought in 20 new patients.
On paper, the first campaign looks better if you’re comparing lead numbers. But when you look at actual patients, the second campaign performed twice as well, with a cost per new patient of $250 instead of $500.
That’s a pretty big difference.
And it’s why you should be careful when an agency talks about leads without explaining what happens to them afterward.
Ask what they’re actually measuring
When discussing reporting with a potential agency, start with a simple question:
“How will we know whether your marketing is bringing us new patients?”
Pay attention to whether they talk exclusively about advertising metrics or also explain how they connect those numbers to appointments.
What a weak answer sounds like
“We’ll send you monthly reports showing how many clicks and leads your campaigns generated, along with your cost per lead.”
There’s nothing wrong with tracking those numbers. They’re useful for understanding how your advertising performs.
But a lead could be someone who submitted a form, called to ask about pricing, or contacted the practice without ever booking an appointment.
What a better answer sounds like
“We’ll track how many genuine new-patient inquiries your marketing generates, how many turn into booked appointments, and how many patients actually show up. We’ll also work with your front desk to understand why some inquiries aren’t converting.”
For higher-value treatments like implants, veneers, or Invisalign, I’d take this a step further and ask whether the agency can track how many consultations result in treatment starts.
Not every practice will have the systems in place to track all of this immediately. But a good agency should be able to explain what’s possible, what needs to be set up, and how they’ll use that information to improve your marketing.
Before signing, ask to see a sample report and have them walk you through it. Make sure you understand what they count as a lead, how appointments are measured, and what decisions they make based on those results.
Key takeaway: An agency shouldn’t just show you how many people contacted your practice. It should help you understand how many became patients and what can be improved along the way.
3. Do they have experience that’s relevant to your practice?
Let’s say you’re comparing dental marketing agencies and one proudly advertises:
“300% increase in dental leads!”
Sounds pretty impressive, right?
Well, it depends.
Going from three leads to 12 is also a 300% increase.
That’s why marketing results need context.
Whenever an agency presents a case study, ask for the starting numbers, timeframe, and advertising budget.
It’s also worth understanding what else changed during that period.
Did the practice hire another dentist? Open a new location? Introduce a promotion? Add a high-demand treatment?
These details matter because marketing rarely operates in isolation.
An example from our work with Swish Dental
One of our own case studies is Swish Dental, a dental group in Texas.
During our partnership, Swish grew from 10 to 23 locations, with our team managing advertising to support its expansion.
That’s a result we’re proud to be associated with.
But here’s what I wouldn’t tell you.
I wouldn’t claim that our advertising alone was responsible for opening 13 new locations.
And I wouldn’t suggest that a single-location dental practice should expect the same outcome from its marketing budget.
Swish had its own growth strategy, team, operational decisions, and expansion plans. Our role was to support that growth through advertising.
What matters when evaluating this case study is understanding what we actually did, how we measured performance, and which parts of that experience could apply to another practice.
That’s how I’d recommend looking at any agency’s case studies, including ours.
Look for a comparable challenge, not just a recognizable logo
An agency might have worked with a large dental group, but that doesn’t automatically make it the best choice for a small independent practice.
Likewise, an agency with excellent general dentistry results might not have much experience promoting full-mouth dental implants.
Ask yourself whether the case study reflects the challenges your practice is facing.
And don’t stop at the headline numbers.
Ask to see examples of the actual work. That could be a landing page, advertising campaign, or follow-up process.
You should also ask whether the result being presented is typical or unusually successful.
Here’s another question most practices forget to ask
“Can I speak with one of your current or previous clients?”
A reference can tell you things a case study can’t.
But instead of simply asking whether the client is happy, try something more specific:
“Can you give me an example of how the agency handled a disappointing month or a problem with your campaigns?”
Every agency experiences difficult months. Even good campaigns go through periods of weaker performance.
What’s more important is how the agency responds.
Do they investigate what went wrong? Explain the situation? Suggest practical changes?
Or do they disappear until the next monthly report?
Key takeaway: Look beyond impressive percentages and big-name clients. Ask for the numbers behind the results, examples of the actual work, and evidence that relates to your practice.
4. Who will actually be responsible for your marketing?
Here’s something I hear quite often when speaking with dental practice owners.
Everything was great at the beginning.
The sales team was responsive, communication was excellent, and everyone seemed genuinely interested in helping the practice grow.
Then, a few months into the relationship, things changed.
Emails took longer to answer. Reports arrived without much explanation. It became difficult to understand who was actually managing the campaigns.
And the practice no longer felt like a priority.
This is why I’d strongly recommend understanding who you’ll be working with after the sales process is over.
Who’s doing the actual work?
At some agencies, you’ll speak primarily with an account manager who passes information between you and the specialists running your campaigns.
That structure isn’t necessarily bad, especially in larger organizations.
But it can become frustrating when you have a question about performance and the person you’re speaking with can’t explain what’s happening.
At Growdent, we’ve chosen to stay a relatively small agency and keep our delivery in-house.
That means our clients can communicate directly with the people responsible for their marketing rather than going through several layers of account management.
It’s an approach that works well for us, but different agency structures can work, too.
What’s important is knowing how communication and accountability will work before you sign.
Questions worth asking
Find out who makes strategic decisions, how involved senior team members are, and whether you’ll have direct access to the people working on your campaigns.
I’d also recommend meeting the person who would lead your account.
Then ask how often you’ll review progress, how urgent issues are handled, and what response times you can expect.
And there’s one more thing.
Ask to see an example of a monthly report.
Not just the metrics. Look at the explanations.
Does it tell you what the agency learned? What changes were made? What they’re planning to test next?
A report showing that your campaigns received 500 clicks and generated 25 leads is an activity summary.
A report explaining why conversion rates dropped, what was changed, and how the team plans to improve performance is something much more useful.
You want to understand the decisions behind your marketing.
What if the agency uses AI?
There’s nothing inherently wrong with using AI in marketing. We use technology to make our work more efficient, too.
But if an agency makes AI a central part of its pitch, ask what that actually means.
What will AI handle? What will a person review? How will it improve your results?
“AI-powered marketing” isn’t much of an explanation by itself.
Key takeaway: Before hiring a dental marketing agency, find out who’s responsible for your account, how you’ll communicate, and how the team handles problems when things don’t go according to plan.
5. What are you paying for, and what stays under your control?
Let’s say you’re comparing two dental marketing agencies.
One charges $1,500 per month. Another charges $2,500.
The first one looks considerably cheaper.
But what if the $1,500 fee only includes managing Google Ads?
Meanwhile, the second agency includes campaign management, landing pages, creative production, tracking, and conversion optimization.
Suddenly, the comparison becomes a lot less straightforward.
That’s why you need to understand exactly what’s included before comparing prices.
Understand the full cost of dental marketing
Start with the monthly management fee.
Then ask how much you’ll need to spend separately on advertising.
You’ll also want to know whether services such as landing page development, ad creative, tracking implementation, and website changes are included or billed separately.
And don’t forget to check the minimum contract length, cancellation notice, and any additional fees.
A lower monthly price isn’t necessarily better if you’re paying extra for everything needed to make the campaigns work.
Of course, this doesn’t mean you should always choose the more expensive agency.
It means you should compare what you’re actually getting.
Make sure you own your marketing assets
This is an equally important part of the conversation, and one that dental practices sometimes overlook.
Your practice should remain in control of its website, advertising accounts, analytics, and other essential marketing assets.
That includes administrative access to:
- Your domain and website
- Google Ads and other advertising accounts
- Google Analytics and relevant tracking platforms
- Google Business Profile
Why does this matter?
Because you might decide to change agencies someday.
Maybe your practice has outgrown the current arrangement. Maybe you’re unhappy with the results. Or perhaps you’ve decided to bring your marketing in-house.
Whatever the reason, you shouldn’t have to rebuild your entire marketing setup just because you’re leaving an agency.
You should be able to retain your advertising history, access your data, and continue running your campaigns.
Before signing, ask two questions:
“What stays with us if we leave?”
And:
“Is there anything that cannot be transferred?”
An agency should be transparent about ownership, licensing, and any third-party tools that may not transfer.
At Growdent, we believe your website and marketing accounts should remain yours.
An agency should earn your continued business through its work, not by making it difficult for you to leave.
One more thing: HIPAA and patient privacy
If you’re running a dental practice in the United States, there’s another issue you shouldn’t overlook.
Your marketing agency may be collecting and processing information from prospective patients through forms, call tracking, analytics, and advertising tools.
That means patient privacy needs to be part of the conversation.
Ask your agency what information its forms and tracking tools collect, where that information goes, and whether the agency or any vendors require a Business Associate Agreement (BAA).
A useful question is:
“Can you walk me through what happens when someone submits a form on our website and explain which tools receive that information?”
You don’t need to become a HIPAA specialist to ask this.
But you should expect a more detailed explanation than simply hearing, “Don’t worry, we’re HIPAA compliant.”
Marketing data flows can be complicated, and the right safeguards depend on what information is collected, how it’s used, and which companies receive it.
If you’d like to understand the subject in more detail, we’ve also written a guide to HIPAA-compliant dental marketing.
Key takeaway: Compare the full scope of services, not just monthly fees. Make sure you control your marketing assets and understand how the agency handles patient information.
Conclusion: How to choose a dental marketing agency
Hiring a dental marketing agency shouldn’t come down to who has the most impressive website or the most persuasive sales pitch.
Before making your decision, ask these five questions:
- Do they understand your practice? Can they explain what they’d prioritize and why?
- How will they measure success? Are they tracking leads alone, or connecting marketing to actual appointments and patients?
- Do they have relevant experience? Can they show you meaningful results and explain what contributed to them?
- Who will you work with? Do you know who’s responsible for your marketing and how they’ll communicate?
- What are you paying for, and what do you control? Is the scope clear, are patient privacy requirements addressed, and will your accounts remain yours?
You don’t need an agency that promises extraordinary results on the first call.
You need one that understands your situation, can explain its recommendations, provides evidence you can evaluate, and takes responsibility for the work.
And if an agency can’t give you clear answers to these questions before you’ve signed, it’s worth considering what communication might look like six months into the relationship.
Want a second opinion on your dental marketing?
At Growdent, we offer a practice growth session where we’ll discuss your goals, review your current marketing, and explain what we’d prioritize first.
We’ll also tell you whether we think Growdent is the right fit for your practice.